Nat Crits of 19: Trial of the Take Part 2

Very special thanks to @markus2002 for beasting through these stats, as well!

Critical Wins

  • Percy (00:11:35) Initiative vs. Frost Giants
  • Lyra (00:11:35) Initiative vs. Frost Giantsl
  • Vex’ahlia (1:51:27) Sstealth check in Rimefang’s lair
  • Percy (1:59:35) Initiative vs. Rimefang
  • Vex’ahlia (1:59:35) Initiative vs. Rimefang
  • Scanlan (2:08:00) Wis save, resist Terrifying Presence
  • Percy (2:21:58) Attack vs. Rimefang (negated by disadvantage)
  • Trinket (2:27:04) Wis save vs. fear
  • Percy (2:45:40) Wis save vs. fear (after bomb detonation)
  • Grog (2:54:48) Scanlan bowling
  • Vex’ahlia (3:08:08) Wis save vs. fear
  • Vex’ahlia (3:35:27) Perception check for “shinies” in Rimefang’s lair

Critical Fails

  • Grog (00:16:10) Persuasion vs. frost giants
  • Grog (00:41:30) Persuasion vs. frost giants
  • Zahra (00:50:20) Perception check in mountain
  • Lyra (1:59:35) Initiative vs. Rimefang (-1 after modifier!)

DM Rolls

  • Rimefang (Nat20, 2:43:43) Tail attack vs. Scanlan (legendary action)
  • Rimefang (Nat20, 3:16:03) Tail attack vs. Percy (legendary action)

Nat Crits of 18: Trial of the Take Part 1

Special thanks to @markus2002 for beasting through these stats!

Critical Wins

  • Percy (1:44:27) Attack vs. half-ogre, half-orc with pepperbox
  • Percy (1:46:51) Attack vs. orc 1 with pepperbox
  • Percy (2:04:52) Attack vs. orc 2 with pepperbox
  • Vex’ahlia (2:23:56) Con save vs. cold weather

Critical Fails

  • Zahra (00:49:50) Religion check on statue

DM Rolls

  • Direwolf (Nat20, 1:41:35) Attack vs. Grog with advantage

Nat Crits of 17: Hubris

Critical Wins

  • Tiberius (0:23:10) Religion check vs. Statue
  • Percy (0:23:10) Religion check vs. Statue
  • Vex’ahlia (2:05:13) Tracking the Hydra
  • Vex’ahlia (2:13:39) Stealth vs. Hydra
  • Tiberius (2:35:33) Telekinesis vs. Hydra head
  • Vex’ahlia (2:40:00) Dex save vs. exploding arrow
  • Percy (2:48:28) Wis save to shrug off Hold Person

Critical Fails

  • Percy (2:31:07) Misfire vs. Hydra
  • Vex’ahlia (2:39:19) Misfiring the exploding arrow
  • Percy (2:45:46) Wis save vs. Hold Person

DM Rolls

  • Kern (Nat1, 0:52:05) Frenzied attack vs. Grog
  • Hydra head (Nat20, 2:37:34) Attack vs. Grog

Anonymous said: Hey dude, just letting you know you should add a (negated by disadvantage) next to Pike's Nat20 vs Red Dragon. You've taken on a mammoth-sized task trying to catalogue the stats (and much more) of 65+ hours of footage. So thanks, it's seriously appreciated.

Thanks! It has been added. It has been a pretty big task, made all that much easier by amazing people like you. Even with an army of Critters, we’re bound to miss something. If any of you catch something that we missed or mislogged here, let us know. We want to be objective here!

Nat Crits of 16: Enter Vasselheim

Critical Wins

  • Keyleth (0:53:51) Eagle-eyed perception check
  • Vax’ildan (1:29:45) Dex save vs. Pillar trap
  • Pike (2:04:36) Initiative vs. Spiders
  • Grog (2:27:50) Stealth check vs. Spiders
  • Pike (2:42:45) Wisdom check vs. Misty Room of Fire
  • Keyleth (2:13:40) nature check vs. Spiders

Critical Fails

  • Grog (0:14:50) Sleep check vs. Rope beard
  • Vex’ahlia (0:43:30) Stealth across Vasselheim’s rooftops
  • Vax’ildan (1:23:13) Perception check vs. mist room
  • Percy (2:17:25) Con save vs. Spider poison

DM Rolls

  • Kima (Nat1, 2:39:06) Dex check vs. Platinum Golems

Nat Crits of 15: Skyward

Special thanks to a critter for assisting with these stats!

Critical Wins

  • Percy (0:53:30) Constructing exploding arrow
  • Tiberius (2:44:25) Telekineses vs. pirate elf
  • Grog (2:46:10) Frenzied attack vs. wyvern

Critical Fails

  • Pike (2:33:41) Attack vs. wyvern
  • Trinket (2:37:54) Attack vs. wyvern

DM Rolls

  • Wyvern (Nat20, 2:52:48) Stinger attack vs. Vax’ildan
  • Airship guard (Nat20, 3:08:16) Point-blank shot vs. Griffin

Nat Crits of 22: AraMente to Pyrah

Critical Wins

  • Vex’ahlia (0:20:23) Religion check vs. Ioun symbol
  • Vex’ahlia (1:50:00) Warhorse negotiation
  • Pike (3:14:50) Stealth vs. Red Dragon (negated by disadvantage)
  • Vex’ahlia (3:27:42) Attack vs. Elemental 2
  • Vax’ildan (3:59:54) Attack vs. Elemental 1

Critical Fails

  • Grog (2:26:30) Perception vs. avalanche sources
  • Vax’ildan (2:28:56) Dex check vs. Ettin boulder
  • Keyleth (3:10:44) Wis check to find signs of mother (negated by advantage)
  • Percy (3:19:15) Initiative vs. Fire Druid Elementals
  • Grog (3:19:15) Initiative vs. Fire Druid Elementals
  • Tiberius (3:22:07) Dex Save vs. Fire Elemental 1 attack
  • Vex’ahlia (3:12:35) Acrobatic check from portal
  • Tiberius (3:12:35) Acrobatic check from portal

DM Rolls

  • Boulder (Nat1, 2:34:17) Str save vs. Tiberius’s telekinesis
  • Fire Elemental 1 (Nat20, 3:41:48) Attack vs. Grog
  • Fire Elemental 2 (Nat20, 3:48:40) Dex save vs. Glacial Blast (negated by disadvantage)
  • Fire Elemental 3 (Nat20, 3:50:00) Attack vs. Pike

Monster Analysis: Fire Elementals

  • First Appearance: 22 AraMente to Pyrah
  • Armor Class 13
  • Challenge Rating: 5 each (MM), ~11 (CR)
  • Darkvision 60 ft, Passive 10
  • Immune to Fire and Poison damage
  • Immune to exhaustion, grapple, paralysis, petrification, poison, prone, restrained, unconscious
  • Resistant to nonmagical physical weapons
  • Speed 50 ft.
  • Avg/Max HP: 102/156
  • Cerkonos: 232 received, 41 finishing blows by Vax 
  • Elemental 2: 108 received, 17 finishing blow by Tiberius
  • Elemental 3: 106 received, 35 finishing blows by Percy

As we saw in combat, fire spreads. When inflicted, failed saving throws forced party members to spend a turn making sure it didn’t consumer their clothing. Melee attacks against it also splash fire back at the attacker. The elementals could have also attempted to occupy the same space as their opponents, automatically setting the creature on fire. (We saw Keyleth attempt the Water Elemental equivalent, which would have grappled if Fire Elementals were capable of being grabbed.)

Fire Elementals are susceptible to water, as Keyleth pointed out. This should not be confused with vulnerability, as Fire Elementals are not vulnerable to anything. This susceptibility adds an extra point of cold damage for every water-based attack it takes. Tiberius’s glacial blasts were also only as effective as their base values, but were certainly more useful in the battle than an array of fireballs.

The three druids-as-fire-elementals were also much more preferable to an ancient red dragon, who, even without its HP amplified as Rimefang’s was, would have had a challenge rating of 24, minus lair actions. Such an encounter would likely have resulted in a chase instead of a battle, both due to the party’s relatively under-leveled abilities and the fact that the episode ran long without the added encounter. Plus, the approaching storm would have added to the urgency, and Keyleth would possibly have to reattempt her AraMente.

It’s difficult to pick an MVP from this battle. The minor elementals received the majority of their damage from Vex, whose focus allowed the rest of the team to concentrate their efforts on Cerkonos. Vax’s magical daggers inflicted the most damage against Cerkonos. The elementals did not really concentrate their attacks, allowing the trial to be a story-oriented encounter over a grand challenge. (And if I may be less objective and number-oriented here, Marisha did an amazing job this episode.)

Critter Requests!

We’ve received a couple of great asks from Critters, and rest assured, we are working on them. Since most of these answers require a lot of time to compute, we’ve created the Critter Request page. This holds the current queue of projects we’re working on. This is also in place to acknowledge that we got your request (since Tumblr isn’t really a good system for messaging). If you’re curious if we got your request or just want to know what someone else wants to know, check it out.

In general, you can expect your request to be added to it within a day or two. Time to calculate varies with the request, the number of volunteers we have, and the relevant episode count (which only grows over time). We’ll always try to answer your ask directly once we know the answer.

Thanks again to our requesters, and BIG BIG BIG thanks to our volunteers!

If you guys watched the broadcast last night, “Internet” was another name for “Critical Role Stats.”

To be perfectly honest, I don’t feel like rewatching the entire series looking out for Orion saying “Nope” after he rolls. Since there is no new episode next week, I imagine most of you are already going to be rewatching. All I ask is that if you see a moment where Tiberius says “Nope” after a roll, message me the episode and time, and we can check it out and update the Nat1 count. The count will stay with Tiberius’s two confirmed Nat1s in the meantime.

While we wait for the next episode, we’ll have more content throughout the next two weeks concerning other stats and past encounters. If you’d like to help contribute either to the workload or the relief of it, the Ask box is always open!